A New Year’s Day Open House

This year will mark our 15th year living in New York City. That meant it was time for a party -a BIG party for all the wonderful friends we’ve made over the past 15 years. And what better day than New Year’s Day?

Now, any normal person planning such a thing would make a guest list and send out invitations with RSVP’s, plan the menu at least two weeks ahead, and start cooking a week ahead and freeze the make-ahead stuff…You know, the right way to have a big party.

Let’s just say we didn’t do it that way.

Two days before Christmas, when I still hadn’t sent out invitations, Mr TBTAM just started e-mailing his tennis buddies that we were having a party. That meant I’d better get a move or none of my friends would be there. So two days after Christmas, while we were driving back from Philly, I went through the contact list on my phone and began calling my friends. I had no idea who was in or out of town, but no one was home so I just left messages everywhere. The connection was probably terrible, because one friends called me back saying “I think you are inviting me to something, but I couldn’t understand a word you were saying”.

Then I got sick. Really sick for the rest of the week. On New Year’s Eve morning, I awoke with a whopping headache, but we finalized the menu and headed out to shop. Somewhere between Costco and Fairway, I realized I was feeling better. Really good, actually. Either the Imitrex had kicked in or the cold had run its course. Praising Big Pharma, I headed into the kitchen where we spent the remainder of the day, only stopping briefly at midnight to run up to the roof with the kids to scream Happy New Year and have some sparkling cider. By 1 am, we were all in bed, only to rise at 9 to start cooking again.

The party was to start at 12 pm. My friend Mark arrived shortly thereafter, having just come off the morning shift at his deli. He helped my glaze the ham and arranged the salmon tartare and egg salad platters as only a real foodie can, then left. By 1 pm, when no one else had arrived and the girls were sure our party would like the one Michael threw at the Convention in “The Ofiice”.

But they were wrong – by 1:30pm, we were in full swing.

Overall about 60 folks came, and from the post party calls and emails, I think they all had a good time. I know we did. So many wonderful people, such dear friends. What was so great was seeing folks from the disparate parts of our lives talking and getting to know one another. I can’t think of any better way to start the New Year.

Of course, not everyone could make it with such short notice, and I had accidentally missed inviting a few wonderful people since their numbers were out of date in my phone. That’s the price I paid for not doing this thing so last minute.

Next year I’ll do it right.

Menu for a New Year’s Day Open House (Feeds 60 guests)

This menu will work for a mixed vegetarian-carnivore crowd, and has some healthy choices for folks trying to keep New Year’s Resolutions. Unfortunately, it has nothing for the Jewish meat eaters, as noted my friend Andy with the comment that “Grammie Hall would have loved the ham”. So next year I’m doing a beef tenderloin instead of a ham.

Guests will need to supplement this menu with desserts, as did ours, and thank goodness – most everything went!

You’ll need to do some cooking, reheating and restocking during the party to keep the food supplies fresh, but making the streudel and quiches ahead makes this easy, and you get some nice time in the kitchen with good friends who offer to help.

I’ll be posting the recipes for some of these things in the days to come, and will insert the links then.

  • 1 glazed Spiral-Cut Ham served with rolls, mustard and mayo. We got the ham at Costco. Heat and serve the day of party
  • 8 Mushroom Strudels – Double the recipe that will follow this post – Can be made ahead and frozen, then baked as needed for the party
  • 3 leek-red pepper quiches – Omit the sausages. Make and freeze unbaked crusts ahead, prepare filling the night before and refrigerate, then prebake crusts, fill and bake the morning of the party. Can be refigerated after baking and reheated as needed during the party.
  • Marinated Asparagus -This is incredibly delicious! Double the recipe. Make a day ahead and serve at room temp.
  • Salmon tartare with dill sour cream and baked pumpernickel toast points – Tartare and sour cream can be made ahead and refrigerated. Recipe will follow
  • Egg Mold with crackers -Make a day ahead. Recipe will follow. Toast points is more proper, this was easier.
  • Veggie Crudites with Spinach Dip – We got the dip at Costco. I prefer homemade.
  • Vegetable Pate -From Fairway, but next year I’m going to try to make my own pates.
  • Cheese Platter with grapes and a fig cake.
  • Gerties’ Artichoke Dip with Milton’s Multi-Grain Crackers -Thanks, again, Costco!
  • A bowl of Clementimes for peeling and eating
  • Dates stuffed with cream cheese and an almond – That’s the recipe
  • Spiced Pecans (any recipe you like for this will do) and Dried Apricots
  • Apricot Squares – Thanks, Martha & Mary!
  • Lemon Tart – Recipe will follow
  • Pineapple and Strawberries
  • Apple Torte
  • Assorted desserts brought by friends
  • Drinks – Champagne, Wine, Beer, non-alcohol grape bubbly and Martinelli’s Sparkling Cider, sodas and Pellegrino

    Happy New Year!

  • 6 Responses to A New Year’s Day Open House

    1. Sounds like a great party. I agree completely that Costco is the first stop when you’re shopping for party food.

    2. Thank you TBTAM. That mushroom streudel was entirely memorable, as were many of the delicacies listed, so thanks for the rushing around on all of our behalf. Our box of chocolate covered toffee crunch from Dylan’s was a distant second to the one that got away on the downtown #4 train, in a decorated Christmas bag, all pretty and tied with green yarn. I hope someone a lot hungrier than we opened and enjoyed the confections within.

      So for the record, being a Grecophile, I thought you’d appreciate some kourabiedes – Greek Christmas/New Year’s cookies – which I bought in Astoria. Not that we need all that butter and sugar melt-in-your-mouthness,, but put me down for Greek confections to bring to the next TBTAM Family party!

    3. You’re bummed that you moved? I’m bummed that I didn’t get invited!!!!
      Certainly sets the bar for next year.
      Sounds like a wonderful event, I’m inspired, I pulled out all my recipes and started cooking!

      I made a wonderful brussel sprouts and pearl onions dish – I carmelized the onions, while reducing a glaze of balsamic vinegar, added these 2 to the steamed brussel sprouts. Even my picky daughter ate this.

      Thx TBTAM for inspiration!

    4. I can almost taste everything. Sounds delicious. Next time you’ll do it “my way”. Mushroom strudel (note spelling) 2 weeks in advance. You’re amazing, headache, cold and all.

    Leave a Reply